The Blue Angels would be proud to pass this close in a cross over !
I just threw up a little. Fate is the hunter…
I just started reading it (again)…
Dumb luck or just plain dumb? That is the question…
But what I don’t understand is why don’t I hear a ”CLIMB!” and associated expletives?
I mean, the guy saw it in time to film it…
Both Cav , I mean the guy passing under has to be dumber than a bag of Hammers. It also had to be pure luck that the Pilot in the Aircraft that was above , above being a very relative term here, did not see him sooner as most peoples instincts would be to either dive and turn, or they might possibly flinch or such and the slightest change in attitude of the top aircraft and we just get a story about a Mid-Air. Video would have been gone with the wreckage.
I do not think the pilot up top had any recognition at all of the dire situation coming towards him at some serious speed, till things were so far into the red zone his mind did not even have time to process what was actually happening .I am guessing that was a Blessing that he may not have.
On the other end of the spectrum , Harrison Ford there in the crossing aircraft needs his license pulled / suspended immediately . Then a good arse whooping might not be a bad idea either , do him / her some good .
I am like @BeachAV8R , I threw up a little in my mouth first time I saw that. Scared the hell out of me just watching it . Will certainly make one hell of a Safety awareness training / re-training video for sure .
Was flying with my Dad many years ago , we were about 35 miles or so North of San Diego . I just happened to look up and say “hey dad look at that 747” , had to be 3 miles out at One O’clock High. Next thing I know, we were in a very interesting dive and turn. I mean that was 3 miles and I still will never forget that.
This one, was about 3 feet, or less ! Its horrifying to even think about that. I bet that top pilot has been throwing up and shaking non-stop since this happened.
I think that was as clueless a passenger / co-pilot as one could ever have . I wondered that myself , but might be a good thing they did not since all turned out ok.
Still, I agree, with the lead time to get your phone or camera and start filming , there is plenty of time for a fire walled Throttle and climb to the moon.
Regarding the guy filming…some posts (Tweets) on the original post have been slamming him for not issuing a warning…which would have been nice.
I recall going to the Red Flag safety brief at Nellis AFB (not the DCS version; the RL version). Most of it was about Low Levels and terrain avoidance…which we learned was a good thing.
They also had a small section about photography and filming from the cockpit, especially in single seat jets. (This was 1987, personal video cameras were still a bit big for a cockpit but 8mm movie cameras were not)
We were told that a couple of things happen:
First, the view through the view finder of a camera (in this case the phone screen) does not accurately portray reality. It like the “Objects in Mirror are Closer than they Appear” warning. What you see is often just not where you are. It also limits your view (more so with view finders) so you lose peripheral vision cues. They illustrated all this with 8mm film recovered from an A-7 crash. It all looks normal until tree branches enter the frame a split second before impact.
Second is fixation: When it is in a view finder (or on a screen), it sucks your attention. You can very easily lose SA of what is going on around you. Your focus is the screen and that’s it.
Not defending the passenger, just a potential explanation of what was/wasn’t going through his brain at the time.
…this might be a good place for a GoPro™ advertisement.
Someone should be filling out an airprox report and taking a lesson in what 500ft looks like
If this was uncontrolled airspace, which I think it was, both aircraft may very well be at the correct altitude.
The right of way for converging aircraft says the overtaking aircraft should change its course to the right. But who is overtaking who?
Uncontrolled airspace VFR is all about see and be seen. This is also a classic case of a high wing aircraft passing below a low wing aircraft. Both pilots are at a visual disadvantage.
Yeah, hate to say it, but “been there”…
Wattisham, K-8 off the top of a winch launch. Spotted the 172 head on, dead ahead, as I was lowering the nose from the launch and could almost see my reflection in the chrome spinner. Kept pushing over. With the thought (funny what you think) “regulations say turn right”, I started applying right rudder to skid away to the right, as I did not want to lift the wing into the path of the oncoming aircraft until I was well below. I heard it go over the top of me, and its shadow flicked through my cockpit. I turned 180 degrees to the right with a 90 degree bank so that I could see it ahead, its shape retreating away. And I laughed, as it had been quite exciting. Must have only been seconds.
How it happened. Rewind to just before the launch. I was in the K-8, behind me in the queue for the next launch was a K-13 with a girl who was going to go solo. They wanted me out of the way quickly, it seemed. As soon as I had closed the canopy, before I had finished all my checks (including the look out above), they hooked me up to the cable and started taking in the slack. I had only just finished checking air brakes in and locked when I heard “all out”, and I was launched.
When I landed five minutes later, everyone was still in shock, and I was asked if that was as close as it had looked from their perspective.“Closer”, I said, grinning and still a bit elated. I filled in the air miss report with the chief flying instructor. (Things sunk in a bit later, I add).
When I got the results, it was found to be a foreign pilot, in a flight from the local flying club we had suspected, who said he found it hard to fill out the report because he had seen nothing. Head down on the map, that moment.
My conclusions, years later (this was in the '90s)…
Primarily MY fault. I could have abandoned the launch before it even started by simply pulling the release and saying “I am not ready, yet”.
If you fly solo, be careful. You have multiple tasks that can distract you from looking out for number one, and no extra set of eyes to help you sitting next to you.
If you do have an extra set of eyes, brief them. As we see in this video, it is pointless to have someone there who is not going to give a timely warning. In airlines (at least the one I was in), the cockpit jump seat briefing included a part about looking out, and mentioning anything that appeared to be a potential hazard. I have another story on that, but some other time
I still have that air miss report of mine somewhere…
Not so much this as the minimum safe distance for separation in VFR.
Yeah, but that’s if you see the other traffic.
Using the same altitude is allowed, as long as you use lateral separation.
However I still think this is a few boneheads messing around rather than a genuine airprox out of the blue lol
My new favorite thing to write on Mudspike is, flying is safe until it’s not. We’ve all been there. I’ve had two misses that were about as close when I was towing gliders. People fly (flew? not sure yet) through my aerobatic box all the time. Once I chased an intruder (a Cherokee) down and held his wing about 10 feet away. It was a minute before he saw me. . People don’t pay attention to what they are doing. The guy filming was concentrating on filming. He/she was probably looking at the screen and didn’t even notice the trouble they were in until the plane passed. It’s easy to judge people. The internet makes it a pastime.
BCV, I would try to avoid flying on weekends. There are just too many planes, especially near airports, training, getting lunch, enjoying the day. Bumpy, cloudy weekdays are the best!
My first comment is that it seems to happen more when the sun is low on the horizon, and in my case around busy metropolitan areas. Add some afternoon haze and your slant visibility can be largely impaired. Not a factor here for either aircraft. The second is that it is harder for the high aircraft to see the low aircraft, because the latter is somewhat obscured by the darker background. Have had close calls in both situations.
Whew @Victork2 , man BONEHEADS not exactly the term that would come to my mind… .
I dont mind a little fun and horseplay or rough housing with a friend at all. Heck , thats what your buds are for , good game of Basketball with some hard but all in fun fouls every now and then or Flag Football where you accidentally put a crushing tackle on a good friend… , but wow if that is their idea of some kind of a fun thing to do they have ZERO right to a Pilot License in my world .
At best if this was some kind of attempt at being cool or having fun , I hope its a Video Edited HOAX .
That kind of thing , if real and joke or not , is simply screaming in the face of Darwinism or Karma to show up and introduce itself to you .
Its not judgement, its just plain truth to me.
I really want to say that I don’t think so. But; that it occurred to you is a good thing.